EDITORIAL: The Morning After

There was no banner reading “Mission Accomplished” on the back wall on March 30th — exactly one month ago today — when the overwhelming vote in favor of the SAG-AFTRA merger was announced, but there might as well have been. Former AFTRA president John Connolly was quoted as saying, “Message f___ing delivered!” This was an especially triumphant moment for him, as he had presided over the AFTRA side of the previous merger effort that was defeated in 2003.

It was, indeed, an impressive victory, against what often seemed like overwhelming obstacles. However, it would be a significant mistake to look upon merger as somehow magically making everything wonderful. Almost all of the problems that challenged SAG and AFTRA individually before merger remain just as challenging post-merger. New ones are on the horizon.

Merger is, in fact, just the beginning of the journey . . . not the end. Now the hard work starts: The unglamorous work, the difficult work, the work that will test whether the new SAG-AFTRA has what it takes to remain viable and relevant in a media landscape that is in turmoil. It took a certain brand of statesmanship to navigate the merger process. Now we need the kind of statesmanship that will allow SAG-AFTRA to navigate the treacherous waters of being merged. Here are some things we believe are needed:

1.  A Clear Vision.  While no doubt many who voted for merger (and indeed many who voted against it) will probably stop paying much attention in the wake of the merger announcement, there are many others who remain both interested and concerned about the immediate direction of SAG-AFTRA.  It is up to the elected leadership to articulate a vision for this coming transition year, to lay out the union’s priorities, and to set the tone for how the new organization will interface with its membership and its external constituencies.  We believe this should come no later than the conclusion of the first plenary board meeting set for mid-May.

2.  A New Effort at Unity.  SAG-AFTRA must devote conscious attention to making sure all of its pieces are working together in harmony.  There is always a tendency to fall into “us versus them” in a merger situation, whether because of geography or organizational heritage.  It takes genuine effort to avoid this.  Both staff and elected representatives must be alert.

3.  A New Effort at Inclusiveness.  SAG, in particular, has been hobbled by partisanship and cliquishness over recent years.  It is important that the new SAG-AFTRA find ways to build bridges among various factions, and to bring new voices and talent into positions of responsibility.  It would be a shame simply to trade one group of insular insiders for a different group of insular insiders.  We need more than “the usual suspects” to make the kind of progress that is needed.

4.  A New Effort at Openness.  Members need to be kept up-to-date about what is happening with core issues.  While there are undoubtedly matters that require confidentiality, the presumption should be in favor of sharing with members what is happening at the highest levels — both the challenges and the triumphs.

We do not wish to be misunderstood.  We are not predicting doom.  We are predicting success, and would like to see everything done that will help contribute to success.  There is too much hard work at stake to do anything else.

 

Fred Wilhelms, RIP

Those who frequented the Comment areas on the Sagwatch.net blog, as well as a number of other online gathering places for actors, will remember Fred Wilhelms as a blunt-speaking, straight-shooting debunker of countless myths and misunderstandings about SAG, AFTRA, their pension and health plans, and the effects of a SAG/AFTRA merger on all of the above.

A 1977 graduate of Vermont Law School, Fred maintained a law practice in Nashville focusing on the entertainment field, representing artists, songwriters and publishers with a focus on artist rights, royalty recovery and benefit issues.

Pancreatic cancer took Fred from us far too early, on April 24, 2012. He will be missed.

A moving retrospective can be found here.

Bruce Dow Exits as SAG Pension & Health CEO – updated

Bruce Dow, the current CEO of the SAG-Producers Pension & Health Plans and a 28-year employee of the plans, resigned today. Dow had been on medical leave since January, and has been accused of wrongdoing by former employee Craig Simmons. The trustees engaged outside counsel to investigate the allegations and announced in December that the allegations were generally baseless.

Reports from the Los Angeles Times, The Wrap, The Hollywood Reporter, Variety.

–Update-

Statement from the Trustees:

It is with regret that we accept our CEO Bruce Dow’s decision to resign from employment with the Plans. For the last 28 years, Bruce has been instrumental in assisting the Trustees in designing and managing many of the benefit programs actors enjoy today. His ideas and innovation over the years have produced substantial savings for the Plans and excellent benefits for Plan participants. We greatly appreciate the work that Bruce has done for the Plans and are pleased to announce that Bruce will serve as a Consultant to the Plans.

The Board of Trustees has appointed Chris Dowdell as the Interim CEO.  Chris is currently the Plans’ Chief Operating Officer and has been with the Plans for over 20 years.  The Board looks forward to working with Chris in his new capacity.  

Zombie-Like, The Anti-Merger Lawsuit Lurches On

In one of our first posts here we expressed the view that the anti-merger Sheen v. SAG lawsuit filed in February had run out of gas in light of the District Court’s denial of a preliminary injunction and the successful completion of the SAG-AFTRA merger.

Shortly after that, rumors began flying that the Sheen v. SAG plaintiffs had voted to throw in the towel and drop the now-defunct lawsuit. Those rumors have not yet become a reality, however.

Today was the agreed (postponed) date for the Screen Actors Guild to file its answer to the complaint. It did so, even though the Screen Actors Guild no longer technically exists (or is in the process of being wound up). For arcane procedural reasons, it is still named as a defendant, despite efforts to substitute its successor, SAG-AFTRA. It seems strangely appropriate, perhaps, for a ghost of a lawsuit to be pursuing a ghost of an organization.

Our view remains firm that “there is no there there” in this lawsuit. The merger has been completed. The District Court is not going to unwind it. The court has also expressed grave doubt whether plaintiffs have a case, even if by the sterile rules of pleading they have alleged enough to keep the case technically alive. If it’s alive, it’s on life support. And that life support will be shut off unless the plaintiffs are willing to keep paying thousands of dollars to their lawyers in order to keep going.

Last one out please remember to turn off the lights.

SAG-AFTRA’s First Strike?

On May 19-20, the SAG-AFTRA National Board will consider a unanimous recommendation by the Executive Committee to implement a Do Not Work notice against music video productions.

Once implemented, SAG-AFTRA members may not accept employment as performers in any music video not produced under a SAG-AFTRA contract. A Do Not Work order for music videos is a result of the major record labels refusing to agree to a contract that meets the critical needs of music video performers.

This action will affect any SAG-AFTRA member hired to sing, dance, act or otherwise perform as talent on any music video that is not covered by the appropriate SAG-AFTRA contract, except for a royalty artist who is already contractually obligated to deliver certain services under an existing royalty agreement with a record label.  Specifically included are SAG-AFTRA members working as dancers, singers, choreographers, cameo performers, models, actors, and most other talent. SAG-AFTRA members who violate a Do Not Work order can be subject to discipline, up to and including expulsion from membership.

Music Videos: “Do Not Work” Order Recommended by Exec Comm

Announcement sent out earlier today by SAG-AFTRA:

SPECIAL NOTICE TO MEMBERS


On May 19-20, the SAG-AFTRA National Board will consider a unanimous recommendation by the Executive Committee to implement a Do Not Work notice against music video productions.

Once implemented, SAG-AFTRA members may not accept employment as performers in any music video not produced under a SAG-AFTRA contract. A Do Not Work order for music videos is a result of the major record labels refusing to agree to a contract that meets the critical needs of music video performers.

This action will affect any SAG-AFTRA member hired to sing, dance, act or otherwise perform as talent on any music video that is not covered by the appropriate SAG-AFTRA contract, except for a royalty artist who is already contractually obligated to deliver certain services under an existing royalty agreement with a record label.  Specifically included are SAG-AFTRA members working as dancers, singers, choreographers, cameo performers, models, actors, and most other talent. SAG-AFTRA members who violate a Do Not Work order can be subject to discipline, up to and including expulsion from membership.

This action follows performers’ efforts to secure an industry-wide contract for music video work, which most recently involved several rounds of contract discussions with the major record labels throughout 2011. SAG-AFTRA is continuing its efforts to reach agreement with the labels however this action is necessary because the labels have failed to agree to some of the most basic contract terms. Some of the outstanding issues involve guaranteed access to water and toilet facilities, proper safety protections for hard surface dancing, overtime provisions, health and retirement contributions and standardized rates of pay.
Please stand together with your fellow SAG-AFTRA members and fellow performers for safety and dignity on the job.  Together we can ensure a safe and fair future for all of us.

If you have questions or wish to volunteer to support your fellow SAG-AFTRA members who are working to ensure basic union standards on music videos, you can help by contacting:

Randall Himes

Assistant National Executive Director, Sound Recordings at randall.himes@sagaftra.org

Stefanie Taub

National Manager of Sound Recordings, West Coast at stefanie.taub@sagaftra.org

Steve Sidawi

National Organizer/Representative at steve.sidawi@sagaftra.org

The new Do Not Work order, if approved, would mirror an earlier Do Not Work order enacted by the AFTRA board on March 24, 2012, shortly before merger.

The Hollywood Reporter. Variety.

SAG-AFTRA LIVESTREAM: A Call to Action For Women Over 50

Short notice, but here’s something announced a short while ago:

ONLINE LIVESTREAM EVENT TODAY 11 am PT/2 pm ET

Take Back the Work: A Call to Action For Women Over 50

 Do women over 50 today have a chance to avoid becoming invisible on movie and television screens? Don’t miss a special opportunity to participate in this workshop and learn how to impact your employment opportunities with a hands-on call to action, guided by marketing and branding expert Mona Finston and facilitated by Ellen Wacher. Presented by SAG-AFTRA, as conceived and funded by the former SAG National Women’s Committee, Finston will guide participants on how to take back the work that’s traditionally been reserved for the 18 -49 demographic. The call to action will include detailed steps and suggestions on how to build your own brand as well as grass-roots media awareness campaigns.

This workshop will be livestreamed to SAG-AFTRA members.

 When: 2–4pm, Eastern / 11am–1pm, Pacific, Tuesday, April 24

 To access livestream: Visit http://www.sagaftra.org/sag-aftra-livestream-events immediately prior to the start of the event.